Sue's Blog

Showing posts with label Newfoundland and Labrador Hydro. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Newfoundland and Labrador Hydro. Show all posts

Monday, July 07, 2014

Tick-Tock the Muskrat and Election Clock

Tick-Tock Tick-Tock goes the Muskrat Clock. Tick-Tock Tick-Tock goes the Election Clock.

Is Hydro-Quebec sitting back and waiting for a bankrupt project? Is the company watching the mess carefully? You know they are.

The Tories and their continued clinging to power and power are ruining this province and her people. The project is over-budget and delayed. Sadly - it may not be delayed enough.

We need some information quickly.

1. What is the cost of getting out of the Emera contract?
2. What is the REAL supply situation on the Island and what is the REAL industrial demand in Labrador?
3. How much exactly have we spent both already expended and contractually expended?
4. If we stopped the project now - what would be the cost?
5. If we continue what is the cost over 50 years?
6. Are we able to interest industrial customers in the Big Land?
7. What are the PC "protectors of natural resources" doing shipping raw - unprocessed ore?
8. Why should we accept and expect huge cost overruns?
9. Will the Tories commit to not signing any more deals on resource development until the next election?
10. Why are Newfoundlanders and Labradorians willing to work on a project that will harm their children and grandchildren?

Who are the real people behind this deal? Please name those Newfoundlanders and Labradorians who are becoming multi-millionaires either directly or indirectly from the Muskrat deal?

Why are their so many Emera utility trucks on our highways?

Why is Emera servicing any of Newfoundland and Labrador?

Why is Emera getting a piece of the light bill you and I will pay on the Island.

Why are Ed Martin and Gilbert Bennett still on our payroll? 

Wake-up everybody - we are being socially, economically, and voluntarily robbed of our natural wealth and the future wealth of our children. 


Wednesday, July 02, 2014

Muskrat - Incompetence? Corruption? Deliberate lies?

Are you willing to read a paragraph to protect your children and grandchildren?

As Tory MHA's current and past line up to run for the Party leadership remember this: They were all part of the Muskrat fiasco.

Please read an excerpt from an article in the Business Excellence Magazine written late last year.

The most recent project to be completed was the $5 billion Eastmain 1A-Sarcelle-Rupert project, in the James Bay area. It was launched in 2007 with approval to build the Eastmain-1-A and Sarcelle powerhouses and divert part of the Rupert River's flow. The diversion began in 2009, two of the three generating units at Eastmain-1-A powerhouse were commissioned in 2011, the third in January 2012. The first generating unit at Sarcelle powerhouse was commissioned in April 2013 and the two other units have now come on line. “From an environmental and logistic standpoint it was the most challenging project in the history of Hydro-Québec,” he says. “It covers an area the size of some European countries but we were able to bring it in on time and a little under budget so we are very proud of that result.”

We need an investigation to determine what caused the unacceptable overruns in the Muskrat Falls project. We need the senior management of Nalcor to resign. We need to hold this government accountable now.

Ed Martin steps to a mic - declares an 800 million overrun - therefore we the people will pay more - then walks back to his very lucrative job.

Fire Ed Martin and the senior management involved in this project.We don't pay them millions a year to be wrong.

Fire the Tories - insist that they call an election now.

Find out how the external expertise we used to confirm the bad numbers - are themselves in a mess with overruns.

Don't turn away from this robbing of the public purse. Look it square in the eyes. Tell Tom Marshall, John Ottenheimer, Paul Davis, and Steve Kent that we no longer wish to be bamboozled. Show them the door and then see if there is a reason for them to lose their pensionable benefits.

Monday, June 30, 2014

Incompetence of Premier, Govt., Martin and Nalcor Executive

In 1971, _________ created __________ which is a subsidiary of ___________. With over 30 years' experience in large-scale projects, ____________ offers a complete range of services in generation and transmission plant engineering, project management and construction.
Over the years, _______ has also developed particular expertise in remote areas and multicultural environments, as evidenced by its role as prime contractor for one of the largest hydroelectric developments in the world— ___________ of northern ____________—which supplies over 50% of the electricity generated by ___________. This was further demonstrated in the _______________, where ___________ personnel constructed a 220-kV transmission line at altitudes of 4,000 metres or more. Every project presents major challenges, and ____________ has the qualified people to meet them.
Part of the considerable know-how __________ has accumulated over the years rests on the solid relationships it has forged with the people affected by its projects. Developing business partnerships and working in close cooperation with the ________, __________, and ________ communities, for example, as well as working to maximize regional economic spinoffs all attest to __________ expertise in this area.
As master builders, __________ personnel are high-calibre professionals. A multidisciplinary team oversees the completion of every phase of a project, from draft-design, detail engineering, procurement and construction management to environmental monitoring and follow-up.
For ________ clients, the benefits are clear—30 years of experience in managing and completing large-scale construction projects in the energy industry, on schedule and within budget.

Can you fill in the blanks? Answers HERE

If the answers included Nalcor - then we might be okay. If Ed Martin was Thierry Vandal and Gilbert Bennett was Real Laporte then overruns would not be considered "normal" and "expected".

The people of Newfoundland and Labrador deserve competence to be "normal" and "expected". To make matters worse - the nit-wits responsible for mismanagement are not replaced - fired.

You see if Nalcor and the government of Newfoundland and Labrador had sought the advice of Hydro Quebec we might have expected the project to be on-time and on-budget; we might have expected that real customers would be found; we would have expected our energy rates to be stable; we would have expected major industry to consume power and create LONG-term jobs.

Danny - Kathy - and the Tories played the Hydro-Quebec fear and hate card and as a result we have a mess - and our children will have a worse mess. We had "experts" remember - the best "experts" remember?

If an 800 million overrun has become "normal" and "expected" it's time to change our attitudes and our government.

Fire the Nalcor Executive and call an election.

Wednesday, January 08, 2014

Spinmeister Powers Come Clean

Tim Powers is reaching new levels of arrogance as he pontificates on the courage of Tweeters who are opposed to the Muskrat Falls deal.

He questions the courage of the convictions of many Newfoundland and Labrador bloggers and tweeters - because he says they will not go on his open-line show and talk to him directly.

He calls Twitter the cheap seats and tin-foil sales the activity.

Tim Powers you control the mic on your show - therefore one would have to be sufficiently confident that you will use it equitably to allow a contrary Nalcor opinion.

I have every reason to believe this is not the case. I would host your show on alternating dates and would invite people to call - the same way you do - but perhaps different people. In this way you do not control the mic at all times and therefore a thorough debate and discussion could be had.

The criticism's and altering positions that many of us hold and express through twitter and blogs are free from your prejudice interference and control. You can have a 3-4 minute conversation with me - then hang up and spin away for 2 hours. In a real debate this would not occur.

Today you were being challenged rightly on your contractual obligations as a lobbyist for Nalcor - to which predictably you answered in the affirmative - but only after the challenge occurred and also because that information is public - therefore readily available to all. You did however say that your company did work for Nalcor - not that you were the lobbyist.

So for the record:
 
Client name: Nalcor Energy
Lobbyist name: Timothy Powers, Consultant
Initial registration start date: 2006-09-18
Registration status: Active
Registration Number: 777504-14002

Client name: Alderon Iron Ore Corporation
Lobbyist name: Timothy Powers, Consultant
Initial registration start date: 2013-02-01
Registration status: Active
Registration Number: 777504-308605
 
So Mr. Powers you've got a bit of skin in this game and those seeking their positions in mining and energy are using your services to advance their case. 
 
I do have to ask though if you are not in violation of the lobbyist acts either federally or provincially by not adjusting your lobbyist registration activity to include allowing your clients preferential access to a talk show that operates in the jurisdiction where the clients do business.  When your clients come on your show and you carefully guide them through a series of questions - that will permit the advancement of their projects - is this not a lobbyist activity. 
 
For certain however - you are not an independent host of a program - totally arms length from the significant and costly projects being discussed. 
 
You then have the gall to question the courage of those people who choose not to participate in this lobby. Just think for a minute Tim - I or others could go on and do our stint - then you could allow other guests invited or otherwise to come on and spin their tale. In this way you are having the critics dealt with for your clients. Do you get it yet? 
 
Then there's always this:
 
Client name: Efficiency Nova Scotia Corporation
Lobbyist name: Timothy Powers, Consultant
Initial registration start date: 2013-08-21
Registration status: Active
Registration Number: 777504-319585
 

Monday, January 06, 2014

NL Media take heed of the Rob Ford Principle

Another short post:

I like many Newfoundlanders and Labradorians are listening to everything we can on the current crisis in our electrical system.

I like many others are also noticing the careful wording and spin being used by the Premier, Minister Dalley and Ed Martin.

I have noticed that many of the predictable questions asked by the media already have predictable answers at the ready.

Remember the Rob Ford Principle: you didn't ask me the right question.

So either the media gets down and at it or we will have to wait for Kathy and Ed to do a Rob Ford.

I do not expect Kathy or Ed to do that so - can we have the media up the ante or at least keep pace with the tweeters and bloggers? You have direct access to the people responsible - use it to get all the information - not just what they want you to have.


Critical Situation and Crisis - The Premier

This will be a short post:

The Premier on VOCM this morning said "this is not a crisis" over and over.

However - when the Premier was talking about being accountable - open - and transparent about the goings on with our Electrical system the Premier says not now we are in a "critical situation".

Yes Premier - critical political situation while the rest of us are in a crisis.

We need the resignations of two of our employees immediately - the first Premier Kathy Dunderdale and the second CEO Nalcor Ed Martin. Gilbert Bennett should follow close behind them. Then and only then can we really deal with this crisis.

The poles are very much more stable than the polls for the Premier - so her crisis is the poll.

Sunday, January 05, 2014

VP Hydro - Quote of the Decade

Yesterday produced the quote of the decade.

It is one of those statements that needs nothing else said.

It is one of those statements that makes one want to pack up their bags and move from their beloved Newfoundland and Labrador.

It is one of those statements that you consume and consume again - then just shake your head.

Then it Dawn's on you.

These are the experts.

It is time to clean house both politically and corporately within Nalcor.

Here's the quote as reproduced in a CBC story "We don't build the system to meet extreme circumstances, because it becomes very costly," said Henderson. "So what we do is we plan our generation to meet what we'd call a normal cold winter day, and what we'd normally experience."

Friday, July 26, 2013

What was John Ottenheimer talking about?

Okay let's go a step further.

After the signing of the 1999 GWAC agreement between CFLCo - which was refused release by government at the time for: "Commercial agreements such as those among Newfoundland and Labrador Hydro, CF(L)Co and Hydro-Quebec are confidential. If released, they could compromise ongoing negotiations between Newfoundland and Labrador Hydro and Hydro-Quebec related to the Gull Island development. Commercial agreements of this magnitude cannot be negotiated in public."

Then Minister Paul Dicks alluded to John Ottenheimer's concerns which were:
 "It is most inaccurate for Mr. Ottenheimer to suggest that the new Shareholders’ Agreement gives control to Hydro-Quebec, "Mr. Dicks said. "If Mr. Ottenheimer had inquired, he would have found out that Hydro-Quebec previously had many of these rights under previous contractual agreements and the laws of the Canadian Business Corporations’ Act. The Shareholders’ Agreement, which was executed in 1999, serves to recognize many of these rights that were already held by Hydro-Quebec."

Oh yes - the entire Tory caucus had issues with this GWAC/Shareholders Agreement. They had issues regarding control of our energy future under this 1999 agreement.

Dicks also said: there is no circumstance where Hydro-Quebec could gain control over CF(L)Co or dilute Newfoundland and Labrador Hydro’s ownership interest from the current 65.8 per cent.

Yup - that's true but the concern was of management control not actual ownership.

Where have all those concerns gone? 

What did Quebec get by providing and additional 2 billion dollars of revenue for our hydro - over the life of the contract? What did they get. 
 
 

Tuesday, July 31, 2012

Reason for Emera not Hydro Quebec? We Will Pay!

And so the fiasco which is the Muskrat Falls deal with Emera continues.

So how about we ask the following questions:

1. Would Quebec agree to a 20-20 deal that is 20% cost = 20% power output - considering overruns would be at our cost not theirs?

2. Would the construction be cheaper with Quebec?

3. Which company would give us better opportunities into the marketplace?

4. What about the ownership of the transmission route?

In my estimation a deal with Quebec would be more beneficial and could accommodate the Gull Island component as well.

In my estimation a deal with Quebec could give us greater returns at a lower cost.

In my estimation the only thing that is really different about the two potential partners is that Newfoundland and Labrador Hydro and Quebec are Crown Corporations owned by the people - whereas Emera is private.

That means the rich bugs get more and the people get less.

Straight forward explanation for a disaster of a project. 

Better than all of the above - use the power in Labrador with industrial partners.

30 years of gouging so that particular interests make a fortune. That ladies and gentlemen is our history. Congratulations to the current nitwits who are facilitating the giveaway.


Friday, July 06, 2012

Nalcor Responds Again - Leaves More ?????

It would appear that Nalcor responds only after I blog that they are not responding. That being what it is - what did Nalcor say?

I simply want to ascertain if Nalcor/Newfoundland and Labrador Hydro has bylaws - as per legislation - and what those bylaws say with respect to the responsibilities of the Board.

The first go-round the company responded by directing me to a paragraph in the annual report. This time I received a copy of "mandates" of the Boards. Still no "bylaws" - however interesting tidbits.

The "mandates" I received were established in 2010. What were the changes? Why was it changed? Who directed the change?

Within the "mandate" literature the following sentence occurs:

"The Board shall have the accountabilities and responsibilities set out below. In addition, the Board shall perform such duties as may be required under, and act in accordance with, the Corporation’s by-laws."

The bylaws are exactly what I requested from Nalcor in my two previous pieces of correspondence. It is exactly what they have avoided giving me in their two responses. 

They have at least admitted to bylaws albeit inadvertently in the latest reply. 

I will now ask a third time to see the bylaws of a company that I am a shareholder of.

For the record below please find what Nalcor did send and ask yourself - based on the information that has been provided - are the Board members and Chair the BEST choices for our energy company.


 
1. The Board of Directors of Nalcor Energy (the “Board”) is responsible for the stewardship of, and has the duty to supervise the management of, the business and affairs of the Corporation.

2. The Board is appointed by the sole Shareholder, the Province of Newfoundland and Labrador, as represented by the Minister of Natural Resources (the “Shareholder”). The Board is responsible for seeking and recommending suitable Board candidates to the Shareholder.

3. For director appointments, the Shareholder in the appointing Order-in-Council shall specify that the director will continue to serve after the expiration of his/her term until a replacement is appointed. This will ensure continuity on the Board while director replacements are being identified and appointed.

ACCOUNTABILITIES AND RESPONSIBILITIES

The Board shall have the accountabilities and responsibilities set out below. In addition, the Board shall perform such duties as may be required under, and act in accordance with, the Corporation’s by-laws.

1. Corporate Governance

(a) The Board is responsible for developing the Corporation’s approach to corporate governance, including developing appropriate policies and procedures and delegating such other matters as it sees fit to the Corporate Governance Committee for its review and consideration.

(b) The Board is responsible for the Corporation’s approach to its governance relationship with its sole Shareholder to ensure the Corporation can operate independent from the Shareholder.

2. Strategic Planning

The Board is responsible for:

(a) adopting a strategic planning process and approving, on at least an annual basis, a strategic plan which lays out the strategic direction of the Corporation in the context of the opportunities and risks of the business and the business and commercial environment in which it operates;

(b) reviewing and approving the business, financial, strategic and other plans proposed by management to enable the Corporation to execute its strategy; and

(c) adopting processes for monitoring the Corporation’s progress toward its
strategic and operational goals, and to revising and altering its directions to
management in light of changing circumstances affecting the Corporation.

3. Operational and Financial Performance

(a) taking action when corporate performance falls short of its performance targets or other special circumstances warrant;

(b) approving the audited financial statements and management discussion and analysis accompanying such financial statements following a review of the recommendation of the Audit Committee; and

(c) reviewing and approving material transactions outside the ordinary course of
business.

4. Risk Management

The Board is responsible for:

(a) Ensuring that management has a process for identifying the principal risks of the Corporation’s business and ensuring the implementation of appropriate systems to effectively monitor and manage such risks with a view to the long-term viability of the Corporation;

(b) overseeing the integrity of the Corporation’s internal control and management information systems;

(c) approving, and monitoring compliance with, all significant policies and procedures that impact the way in which risk is identified and managed; and

(d) approving policies and procedures designed to ensure that the Corporation operates at all times within applicable laws and regulations.

5. Human Resources Management

(a) The Board, through its Compensation Committee is responsible for maintaining a compensation philosophy and framework that will be utilized by the Corporation and its subsidiaries.

(b) The Board is also responsible for approving the compensation of the President and CEO following a review of the recommendations of the Compensation Committee.

(c) The Board is responsible for ensuring a process is in place to measure the performance of senior executives of the Corporation.

(d) The Board will, to the extent feasible, satisfy itself as to the integrity of the President and CEO and other executive officers, and that the President and CEO and other executive officers create a culture of integrity throughout the organization.

(e) The Board is responsible for ensuring that succession planning programs are in place, including programs to train, develop, monitor and retain senior management, including the President and CEO.

6. Board Meetings and Materials

(a) The Chair, in consultation with the President and CEO and the General Counsel and Secretary, shall develop the agenda for each Board meeting.

(b) Meeting materials shall be provided to directors before each Board meeting in sufficient time to ensure adequate opportunity for review.

(c) Independent directors shall hold regularly scheduled meetings at which nonindependent directors including members of management are not present.

7. Committees of the Board

(a) The Board discharges its responsibilities both directly and through its committees: the Audit Committee, the Corporate Governance Committee, the Compensation Committee, and the Safety, Health and Environment Committee. In addition to these standing Committees, the Board may, from time to time, appoint ad hoc Committees to address certain issues of a more short-term nature.

(b) The Board is responsible for approving the mandates for each Board Committee.

(c) The Board is responsible for the appointment of Committee Chairs and members. The Board has the ability to point and replace Committee Chairs and members as deemed necessary.

(d) To facilitate communication between the Board and each Board Committee, each Committee Chair is responsible for reporting to the Board on material matters considered by the Committee at the first Board meeting after the Committee’s meeting.

DIRECTOR DEVELOPMENT AND EVALUATION

1. Each new director shall participate in the Corporation’s Director Orientation Program and any continuing director development programs.

2. Annually, with the assistance of the Corporate Governance Committee, the Board shall evaluate and review the performance of the Board and the adequacy of this mandate




Monday, June 18, 2012

Nalcor Replies - Does not answer Question


As you are aware - my last post dealt with a simple email request for information to Nalcor.

I asked for: Please advise where I may find a copy of the bylaws outlining the responsibilities of the Board of Directors.

Up until this morning I had not received a reply.

I now have the reply:
    
Good day Ms. Kelland-Dyer,

For information regarding responsibilities of the Board of Directors, please see the Corporate Governance section of Nalcor's 2011 Business and Financial Report (pages 93-96).

Here is a link to the report: http://www.nalcorenergy.com/uploads/file/2011%20Nalcor%20Energy%20Business%20and%20Financial%20Report.pdf

Regards
Merissa
Merissa Wiseman
Senior Communication Advisor - Hydro
Corporate Communication & Shareholder Relations
Newfoundland and Labrador Hydro - a Nalcor Energy company

Needless to say – I know there is an annual report and outside government and the corporation I probably have the largest collection of annual reports on the Corporation from the past 40 years.

So let’s try this again but this time – I will try to make it less simple and more complicated. Considering the corporation could not or would not answer the simple request – I will spruce it up.

This time the request is the following:

Under section 10 of both the the Hydro Corporation Act 2007 and the Energy Corporation Act

Hydro Corporation Act, 2007

10. The board may make by-laws

             (d)  respecting the duties and conduct of the directors and of the officers and employees of the board;
             (i)   generally, for the conduct and management of the affairs of the corporation.


Energy Corporation Act

      10. The board may make by-laws
          
             (d)  respecting the duties and conduct of the directors and of the officers and employees of the corporation;
              (i)  generally, for the conduct and management of the affairs of the corporation.

Please advise if the Board has made bylaws for both the Energy Corporation and the Hydro Corporation respecting subsections 10(d) and (i) of the respective acts.

If these bylaws exist please advise where I may see them.

If they do not please confirm and advise if the general statements found in the annual reports – under corporate governance – act as the sole guidance and literature to define the responsibilities of the Board of Directors. If not what other information exists regarding this matter?

Friday, June 08, 2012

Conflict of Interest in Nalcor Appointments?

The appointment of 4 people today to the Boards of Nalcor and Hydro must now be examined.

What is the relationship of any of these individuals to any MHA or Member of Cabinet?

How can one appoint a currently serving politician to a Crown Corporation?

What are the potential or perceived conflicts of interest?

What are the direct experience levels of these individuals in the field of energy both renewable and non-renewable and also in the area of billion dollar corporations?

Does this essentially mean that they are talking heads for the government?

What are the bylaws outlining the responsibilities of the Board of Directors for these crown companies?

Does the Premier believe that these appointments represent the best expertise available to fill the Boards at such a crucial period?

These are reasonable questions and they deserve answers.




Tuesday, June 05, 2012

Nova Scotians want to Nationalize Emera (NS Power)?

Remember our Power of the People?

Well now there is a Nova Scotian group called Power to the People.

They are calling on Nova Scotia Power (Emera) to be nationalized.

They have a facebook page: PRESS HERE

They have a song on youtube:

They have a website: PRESS HERE

8 Billion in debt for our children - for Power that is not needed - and a deal that will ultimately ruin our Newfoundland and Labrador Hydro.

Nova Scotia privatized at the same time we stopped the privatization of Newfoundland and Labrador Hydro. They are paying a huge price. Stop the ruination of our great company. Demand - as shareholders - that management and executive be replaced by professionals committed to us (the shareholders) not private millionaires looking for a new buck.

We stopped the privatization of NL Hydro to prevent this:

“Nova Scotia Power made $121 million in profits in 2010, while paying their executives millions. With democratic public ownership, that money would stay here in Nova Scotia and be used for public priorities, like hospitals, schools and roads”

Do not let Dunderdale/Williams doomed plan ruin the future for our children. 

Already we are seeing cuts to vital services to subsidize this fiasco.

Stop the deal - shut the GATES!

Sunday, April 08, 2012

Dear Mr. Martin...The Need for Power is???

According to Nalcor Leadership Blog - post author - Ed Martin:

Power is needed for the island and Labrador
Nalcor’s subsidiary, Newfoundland and Labrador Hydro (Hydro), has a responsibility to assess and recommend supply options to meet the province’s growing energy needs. This is a function the company has been performing since the 1970s and its predecessors before it. In 2010, Hydro determined new generation was required to meet the growing demand for electricity on the island.

So Mr. Martin let's start here; if we are at such risk of running out of power - why did you only figure that out after you bailed on the Hydro-Quebec possibility?

Second - please tell the people of Newfoundland and Labrador how many times over the past 40 years that Hydro has stated that we would run out of or need power within 5-10 years of the particular statement?


Thursday, February 09, 2012

Privatization - MUST be the Agenda with Muskrat

After listening and reading ALL the information provided to the public by Government on the Muskrat Falls proposed development - I can only conclude that this deal is the beginning of the process to privatize our company and energy assets.

First the government has admitted in Emera - a Nova Scotian publicly traded company into an ownership position. (temporary or otherwise)

Danny Williams did not "go it alone" as he suggested we would.

Second - the cost to the ratepayers of this development is prohibitive (even at the current estimates) and could be catastrophic if the overruns reach 50%.

Third - We will be sold a bill of goods saying that if the private sector takes it - they might be able to transmit and distribute power more efficiently.

That then clears the way for a fully private development (giveaway) of Gull Island.

Sorry - but from where I sit - nothing else makes sense.

Williams did not oppose the privatization attempt by Clyde Wells - round two?

Sunday, July 03, 2011

Of Mice and Premiers - Time for Dunderdale's Cabinet and Caucus to take a Stand

Let's not get all literal here.

There is a message sometimes that people must listen to and do something about.

The Cabinet and Caucus of Kathy Dunderdale must at least be somewhat concerned about the Premier's choices and loyalties.

Our Premier is now going to challenge Dr.Wade Locke on the definition of "heritage fund" or "legacy fund". Great - another person - not a chosen "official" will be summarily dismissed - despite the value in what he says.

Dear Premier,

Will you please inform the people of the province what your real problem is. Stephen Harper - the man you chose to support in the last election - is the very same man who has denied the children of the province a meaningful play in our oil resources.

You see Premier when the Harper lied and did not remove the non-renewable resource revenues from equalization - he took 10 billion from our children. That is a legacy fund!

When Canada mismanaged our renewable fishery they took away a billion dollars a year from our children. That is renewable industrial heritage!

Yes we are spending budgetary funds on roads, schools, and hospitals - but we are missing billions which could be set aside for the future generations. Once the oil is gone it is gone! You and your cohorts will be held up as inept, unthinking, and generally naive politicians. That apparently is the only lasting legacy of our land and sea.

In Quebec - your territory of jealousy - they not only have amassed great wealth, industry, and employment with resources - they also had an energy trust which seen Quebeckers pay the lowest price for power. What was our reward for the Upper Churchill?

Hydro-Québec buys almost all of the plant's output at one-quarter of a cent per kWh — the exact rate is 0.25425 cents per kWh until 2016 and 0.20 cents for the last 25 years of the contract.

Now Madame Premier - you propose to do the same thing all over again? Not Brinco but Emera, not Hydro-Quebec but Nova Scotia Power.

I do believe it is time your colleagues did the honourable thing and either - demand the Emera deal is shelved - or demand your resignation.

Sincerely,

Sue