Just about 6 years ago - the master negotiator who hated "loopholes you can drive a mack truck through" passed over 8 million dollars in the form of an interest-free loan to Terra Nova Shoes a subsidiary of Kodiak Group Holdings. The loan was to be paid over 10 years - bringing us to 2018.
Okay let's get to the basics - did we have a clause stating the business could not be relocated outside the province for 10 years? Did we have a clause that interest would be added to the loan amount if the company left Newfoundland and Labrador? Did we have a clause that all amounts owing would be immediately payable if the company left the province? So Minister Sullivan tells us to stay calm "these loans are very well secured". So Minister you gave the interest-free 8 million dollar loan in 2008 to be paid by 2018 it is now 2014 6 of 10 years already gone by yet you have only collected 1/4of the money back?
At the time of the loan announcement in 2008 the company said the following:
After considering options for consolidation, the
company chose to base its Canadian operations in Harbour Grace because
of Terra Nova’s strong track record, commitment to quality assurance and
customer satisfaction, and productive and dedicated workforce. The
expansion will realize the addition of approximately 50 new positions at
Harbour Grace, as well as the retention of the over 170 existing staff.
To increase capacity, a 30,000 square-foot extension to the existing
70,000 square-foot facility has been completed.
"We are very excited to be expanding Kodiak’s strong
business model and culture in this region," said Kevin Huckle, President
of Kodiak Group Holdings. "The expansion to this fine facility is a
result of the hard work and dedication of the men and women who work in
our Harbour Grace footwear plant. This activity reveals our strong
commitment to this organization and supports future growth. Kodiak’s
investment demonstrates that manufacturing still plays a crucial role in
Canada’s economy."
At the time of the loan announcement in 2008 - Paul Oram Minister responsible at the time said the following:
"The company’s decision to base its Canadian
operations in Newfoundland and Labrador will strengthen its
competitiveness internationally," (emphasis added)
Here's what the company is saying now:
The company said it has become too expensive to manufacture the
footwear in Newfoundland and then ship them to Ontario for distribution.
The plant in Harbour Grace was built in 1971.
"The reality is the high costs to continue operating the Harbour
Grace plant have become unsustainable over the past several
years," Kodiak president Kevin Huckle said in a statement. (emphasis added)
Here's what Susan Sullivan - Minister responsible is saying now:
"It's very disappointing for us," she said. "We've been working with the
company over the last few days to try to see if there's anything that
we can do to encourage them to stay, but it seems they've made up their
minds, that this is not a place they are able to do business."
So how long has the government known about this?
What did they do to "entice" the company to stay on?
Importantly: Is it possible that there will be people working in a plant in Ontario that is using interest-free money from Newfoundland and Labrador?
What happened to all that savvy in attracting and retaining business?
Once again a long-standing manufacturer/processor - has decided this is not a cost-effective place to do business for them.
Paper mills, fish plants, tech firms, oil refiners, and manufacturers head to the land of the have-not. Any chance to use power to attract industry is being squandered so we can help Canada become "green" and Nova Scotians to get cheaper power. Our proud heritage on the sea - yet where does ship-building go to? Billions in contracts - oh yeah - Nova Scotia.
Perhaps John, Steve, and Paul can create thousands of person-hours of work to tear the facility down. Wait now - we just tore down Stephenville, and we got Grand Falls-Windsor in the wings - that should keep us busy till we have to dismantle Bull Arm.
So should we expect the following slogans?
John - all Nalcor employees to wear Kodiaks
Paul - all Police to wear Kodiaks
Steve - all boy scouts to wear Kodiaks
and you guys had the audacity to crucify Grimes over the only contract without loopholes?
no wait I forgot there is one more contract without loopholes - the Upper Churchill contract.
When listening to the radio, watching television or reading the newspapers about events in this province, there seems to be a missing link. One that bridges all that information together and provides a way for people to contribute, express or lobby their concerns in their own time. After-all, this is our home and everyone cannot fit in Lukie's boat and paddle their way to Upper Canada, nor should we!
Showing posts with label paul oram. Show all posts
Showing posts with label paul oram. Show all posts
Tuesday, July 08, 2014
Wednesday, January 29, 2014
Journalism dealt another blow by James McLeod
This morning - the Telegram has served up another waste of space by "journalist" James McLeod. Under the News section you'll see a story headlined; "Rumours swirl about PC leadership ahead of critical meeting Saturday".
The story begins by outlining rumours about who may seek the leadership of the Newfoundland and Labrador PC Party.
It quickly turns into another Liberal bashing through the bias pen of the reporter.
The subheading reads: "Throwing stones" In this paragraph McLeod talks about tweets by Liberals regarding the Tory delegate style convention. What it does not say - is there have been Tory tweets as well taking smacks at the Liberal convention style.
McLeod then adds that it is unclear what glass ceiling the Liberal party broke as they elected a middle-aged man. If McLeod is using a strict interpretation of glass ceiling - with feminist meaning - then I would suggest - the open leadership of the Liberal party allowed many thousands of women to vote for the next leader - without restriction of finance to attend a convention, without restriction of geography, and without restriction of conflicting commitments to job and family. If one were to use a more broad interpretation of glass ceiling - where men and women could be included in the advancement - then obviously over 20,000 people voting in a leadership election for any party in our province - not only broke it but shattered it.
McLeod then says "it was the PC Party that first put a woman in the role of Premier". If James were actually producing news not spin - he might have opined that there were rumours of backroom deals to keep men interested in the role from running. It is also interesting that McLeod finds that anybody putting a woman anywhere is somehow breaking a glass ceiling.
The next subheading reads: "Delegates decide" - and in that paragraph McLeod paraphrases something allegedly said by PC Party President Sheahan. He said the Liberals were so thoroughly decimated — without active district associations, donors or membership lists — that they needed to use their leadership race to rebuild the mangled party.
Right of the top - this is an example of Tories once again taking smacks at the Liberal process and further ignores the obvious balance to that statement.
The Tories are probably using the delegate style convention because they have been decimated in the polls and must raise some excitement to rebuild the battered party. The rumours of so many people running may simply be a set-up by the PC's in an attempt to show artificial interest in the publicly admonished party. Names like Ottenheimer, Skinner, Manning, and Oram - Tory stalwarts not new blood - and a bunch of Cabinet Ministers positioning themselves to be a king/queen maker.
The other obvious thing here is that the PC's that McLeod says put the female Premier in office - are the same group that so obviously threw her out and the same bunch that are acting now like it was all Dunderdale's fault.
There are some real problems with much that McLeod reports on - but this one is Duffyesque and shows a real bias.
The story begins by outlining rumours about who may seek the leadership of the Newfoundland and Labrador PC Party.
It quickly turns into another Liberal bashing through the bias pen of the reporter.
The subheading reads: "Throwing stones" In this paragraph McLeod talks about tweets by Liberals regarding the Tory delegate style convention. What it does not say - is there have been Tory tweets as well taking smacks at the Liberal convention style.
McLeod then adds that it is unclear what glass ceiling the Liberal party broke as they elected a middle-aged man. If McLeod is using a strict interpretation of glass ceiling - with feminist meaning - then I would suggest - the open leadership of the Liberal party allowed many thousands of women to vote for the next leader - without restriction of finance to attend a convention, without restriction of geography, and without restriction of conflicting commitments to job and family. If one were to use a more broad interpretation of glass ceiling - where men and women could be included in the advancement - then obviously over 20,000 people voting in a leadership election for any party in our province - not only broke it but shattered it.
McLeod then says "it was the PC Party that first put a woman in the role of Premier". If James were actually producing news not spin - he might have opined that there were rumours of backroom deals to keep men interested in the role from running. It is also interesting that McLeod finds that anybody putting a woman anywhere is somehow breaking a glass ceiling.
The next subheading reads: "Delegates decide" - and in that paragraph McLeod paraphrases something allegedly said by PC Party President Sheahan. He said the Liberals were so thoroughly decimated — without active district associations, donors or membership lists — that they needed to use their leadership race to rebuild the mangled party.
Right of the top - this is an example of Tories once again taking smacks at the Liberal process and further ignores the obvious balance to that statement.
The Tories are probably using the delegate style convention because they have been decimated in the polls and must raise some excitement to rebuild the battered party. The rumours of so many people running may simply be a set-up by the PC's in an attempt to show artificial interest in the publicly admonished party. Names like Ottenheimer, Skinner, Manning, and Oram - Tory stalwarts not new blood - and a bunch of Cabinet Ministers positioning themselves to be a king/queen maker.
The other obvious thing here is that the PC's that McLeod says put the female Premier in office - are the same group that so obviously threw her out and the same bunch that are acting now like it was all Dunderdale's fault.
There are some real problems with much that McLeod reports on - but this one is Duffyesque and shows a real bias.
Friday, September 02, 2011
Was Paul Oram in a Conflict of Interest when Trying to Buy Businesses while Minister?
Yesterday Paul Oram, Former Minister of Business and Health decided he would weigh in on the pharmacy issue.
Important questions for Mr. Oram
1. When he was negotiating to buy pharmacies was he the Minister of Business or the Minister of Health?
2. Would he be in conflict when serving as either Minister while at the same time using the knowledge he has in those portfolios and applying that directly to business acquisitions?
3. When Mr. Oram says he would buy pharmacies then or now - what price is he talking about?
4. When Mr. Oram says the pharmacies would have to "adjust their businesses" what does he mean? Is he saying that services would have to be cut for seniors? Would there be mass layoffs? Would the hours and accessibility change?
5. Oram says not "every" rural pharmacy would close - what one's does he believe will close?
6. Did Mr. Oram divulge financial information to his colleagues in government that was attained confidentially?
Mr. Oram remains a voice-box for government and where Minister Tom Marshall silenced all MHA's on the issue publicly (like a dictator) - the government is now going to send out ex-MHA's and ex-Ministers.
Below is the transcript from VOCM's Open-Line
Important questions for Mr. Oram
1. When he was negotiating to buy pharmacies was he the Minister of Business or the Minister of Health?
2. Would he be in conflict when serving as either Minister while at the same time using the knowledge he has in those portfolios and applying that directly to business acquisitions?
3. When Mr. Oram says he would buy pharmacies then or now - what price is he talking about?
4. When Mr. Oram says the pharmacies would have to "adjust their businesses" what does he mean? Is he saying that services would have to be cut for seniors? Would there be mass layoffs? Would the hours and accessibility change?
5. Oram says not "every" rural pharmacy would close - what one's does he believe will close?
6. Did Mr. Oram divulge financial information to his colleagues in government that was attained confidentially?
Mr. Oram remains a voice-box for government and where Minister Tom Marshall silenced all MHA's on the issue publicly (like a dictator) - the government is now going to send out ex-MHA's and ex-Ministers.
Below is the transcript from VOCM's Open-Line
| PAUL ORAM: Yeah, the comments on the pharmacists, talking about pharmacies and so on. You know, we looked at buying a couple of pharmacies a few years ago. I can tell you that, you know, the negotiations stopped because the owners decided not to sell. And it was two independent pharmacies. And I can tell you right now that if the pharmacists and if anybody wants to sell me pharmacies today, I'm open for business. I'll buy them. I mean these pharmacies are making a whole lot of money. The generic drug business is making a whole lot of money. And yes, the margins may be cut a bit. Like everybody we have to adjust our businesses every day for different things to change our margins. But the reality is, these pharmacies are still worth a lot of money. | |
| RANDY SIMMS: So you don't accept the argument from these independent pharmacists that in actual fact the loss of these professional fees or pharmaceutical rebates will mean the demise of their business. You don't believe that. | |
| PAUL ORAM: Absolutely not. They may have to adjust their business somehow to make it work more properly or make it work differently. I mean the reality is that this is a law that's put forth in Canada. These rebates have been coming in and I think government turned a blind eye to it for years. That's the reality. But at the end of the day, they're making a whole lot of money. And should they make money? Yes, they should. I think everybody should make money, you know, and the more they make the better. But you know, the province has an opportunity here to save some money and save a lot of money, by the way. So we have to look at every possible way to save money. I mean this is not the demise of every small pharmacy in rural Newfoundland and Labrador, in Newfoundland and Labrador in general. I mean this is just, this is going to have to be an adjustment that's made by the pharmacies to ensure that they keep their business viable. And I believe these businesses are very viable and I heard some comments -- | |
| RANDY SIMMS: And you, Paul Oram, businessman, you're ready to buy a couple if they're willing to sell them. | |
| PAUL ORAM: I want them. Ask them to give me a call. I'll buy them right now. | |
| RANDY SIMMS: I got to end on that note, Paul. | |
Tuesday, February 06, 2007
Paul Oram joins the fray....
I am disappointed in Paul - he is a new member and was not involved in setting the rules of the IEC in 03-04.
He should not have to pay back his $2875 allowance top-up - what Paul needed to explain is how much was left when Tom Lush left.
Did Tom disproportionately deplete that allowance by election October - 2003?
In order for this to be really corrected the people need the information. Tell us Paul what was in your allowance when you took office?
By saying that he would not have taken it - he is blindly following the spin the Premier is applying. The House of Assembly remains an independent body and should not be dictated to by the Premier or government.
He should not have to pay back his $2875 allowance top-up - what Paul needed to explain is how much was left when Tom Lush left.
Did Tom disproportionately deplete that allowance by election October - 2003?
In order for this to be really corrected the people need the information. Tell us Paul what was in your allowance when you took office?
By saying that he would not have taken it - he is blindly following the spin the Premier is applying. The House of Assembly remains an independent body and should not be dictated to by the Premier or government.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)