Sue's Blog

Showing posts with label oil. Show all posts
Showing posts with label oil. Show all posts

Friday, September 27, 2013

Landmark Oil Find - Great News for ???

The news offshore is good - another significant oil find off the coast of Newfoundland and Labrador.

Hundreds of millions of barrels of light sweet crude - lots of the best.

Now let's look at our cut.

Statoil is owned 67% by the people of Norway. They will be the primary beneficiary of our oil.

Newfoundland and Labrador is still not able to refine any of our own oil. Therefore refineries in Eastern Canada will be the beneficiary of the secondary processing.

Our population is not increasing despite the massive oil, mineral, and energy wealth.

The news is good - yes. The news is great - hardly.

How about our local media do a breakdown of the benefits coming from another of our natural resources. This might tell us and Minister Joan Shea why we have a shrinking aging population despite all the fabulous natural resource headlines.

Ironic - that today we are worried about the potential loss of the Come by Chance refinery where we process oil that is far inferior to our own.

It is superb news for NOIA - it is another sad day for the people of our province. 

Too bad our politicians do not have the vision of their colleagues in Norway.

Population Norway - 1970 - 3.8 million
Population Newfoundland and Labrador - 1970 - 514 thousand

Population Norway - 2012 - 5 million
Population Newfoundland and Labrador - 2012 - 526 thousand

Guess it really depends on what we do with natural resources. Norway and this province are good comparisons relative to energy wealth - both hydro and oil.

This is just another giveaway.

Monday, November 12, 2012

Will Oil Prices really hit Dunderdale Govt. Projections?

As we watch the Muskrat fiasco continue to unfold - one important factor continues to be puzzling.

We already know the Dunderdale administration has been off on oil price projections over 1 year let alone 30-50 years. We also know that Newfoundland and Labrador Hydro has been off on need for power over the past 30 years - however we need them to be spot on now.

How about this headline?

U.S. set to overtake Saudi in oil output: IEA


LONDON--A shale oil boom means the U.S. will overtake Saudi Arabia as the world's largest oil producer by 2020, a radical shift that could profoundly transform not just the world's energy supplies, but also its geopolitics, the International Energy Agency said Monday.
In its closely watched annual World Energy Outlook, the IEA, which advises industrialized nations on their energy policies, said the global energy map, "is being redrawn by the resurgence in oil and gas production in the United States." 

The assessment is in stark contrast with last year, when it envisioned Russia and Saudi Arabia vying for the top position. 

"By around 2020, the United States is projected to become the largest global oil producer" and overtake Saudi Arabia for a time, the agency said. "The result is a continued fall in U.S. oil imports (currently at 20% of its needs) to the extent that North America becomes a net oil exporter around 2030." 

This major shift will be driven by the faster-than-expected development of hydrocarbon resources locked in shale and other tight rock that have just started to be unlocked by a new combination of technologies called hydraulic fracturing. 

According to Washington's Energy Information Administration, U.S. oil production has increased 7% to 10.76 million barrels a day since the IEA's last outlook a year ago. The agency's conclusions are partly backed by the Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries, which last week acknowledged for the first time that shale oil would significantly diminish its share of the U.S. market. 

The group said the U.S. would import less than 2 million barrels a day in 2035, almost three-quarters less than it does today. That's not to say OPEC's role will be marginalized globally. The group's share of global production will increase from 42% today to 50% in 2035, with much of it going to Asia, according to the IEA.

Wednesday, October 31, 2012

PIRA Projections? - Muskrat Nightmare?

The company that supplied Nalcor and the government of Newfoundland and Labrador with projected oil costs has a new focus:

PIRA Energy Group held a seminar that I hope our province attended - before sanctioning the debt elephant and the Muskrat Falls inferior development plan.

It's time for our politicians to stop ignoring or downplaying the shale play in North America. The price of oil - which our reports on Muskrat rely so heavily on - may be taking an absolute turn downward. If this were to happen then our estimates are dead wrong - our export ability is dead, our price for domestic power would be too high, and the debt carried by taxpayers and monies paid by ratepayers would be unacceptable.

This type of error would compare to our failure to recognize the value of hydro - as oil prices soared. Now the opposite may happen - and we need to fully examine this possibility. Just as our mistake in the late 60's has netted Quebec a windfall - this project has the same potential to make multimillionaires of a few while hanging an albatross around the neck of Newfoundland and Labrador for an equivalent number of generations.

Please Read HERE

How about the government show us the latest PIRA report to them on projected oil prices. Where is the new report?

Also please advise if the formula used for projections to determine price of oil for our Hebron equity is the same as that being used for Muskrat.

We need to do more than be force fed fuzzy commercials, dazzled with hotel announcements, and reassured by MHA's who clearly do not have all the information. We need to stop this deal now - have the works go to the Public Utilities Board - which in turn would have complete authority to call any and all witnesses, check the primary data and estimates of Nalcor, and review the energy marketplace for the next 30 years.

We need to be cognizant of the fact that the project estimates have increased by over a billion dollars - which the government says is because of improved engineering and infrastructure plans.

Let's take them at their word. Why were the plans deficient to begin with if we have the BEST experts doing them? If the people, opposition, and media did not complain loudly about the first MHI, Navigant, and Joint Panel Review findings - would the government have proceeded with less than acceptable infrastructure?

If the increased costs are largely due to improper costing - then how do we expect to achieve a 10% maximum on over-runs?

There may very well be a project that works for the Lower Churchill - a domestic project/s that could see partnership between energy intense secondary processing industries and Newfoundland and Labrador Hydro - where transmission costs and energy loss could be minimized by using the power in Labrador. This of course does not include "johnny come lately" panic for Muskrat power when the Emera deal for Nova Scotia power may be in jeopardy and the potential export sales non-existent. We need to start from scratch and determine what is the best project/s for the Lower Churchill resource and proceed from there.

The television commercials and media buy to sell us something we have no say in - is throwing money for roads, hospitals, schools, and health down the drain.

If the government really wants the people to support the project - then send it to the experts we pay to determine the real costs, risks, and options for domestic supply IF and when we may need it.

This project has all the potential of being a second Upper Churchill nightmare - wherein WE make a mistake again.

We keep hearing that could not happen because of all the experts we have. Well how did it happen with the Upper Churchill?

How did the Newfoundland and Labrador Hydro experts get it wrong on privatization?

How did experts with Newfoundland and Labrador Hydro make so many errors in predicting power shortages over the past 30 years?

If and when the Lower Churchill is developed business will make money on the construction, engineering, and management of the project. We cannot just do a project to make business happy now by filling their coffers with contracts - that we have no ability to pay without extreme hardship to our people.

While we are at it - have a look at the mess in Nova Scotia regarding this deal and potential partnership and ask yourself is Emera in this? Are we guaranteed that Emera is in this?

 Please read Here and look at the comments from Nova Scotians. 

We are not yet in a position to sanction this deal and the people must step up and force the government to retreat from this fiasco.

Wednesday, June 27, 2012

Define Moratorium

Moratorium - A SUSPENSION of Activity

So that's where we are? A suspension of activity?

This suspension of activity has caused the loss of over 40,000 people from our province.
This suspension of activity has caused the death or near-death of some rural communities.
This suspension of activity has caused the loss of relationships and breakup of families.
This suspension of activity has caused the closure of secondary related business and industry.

Moratorium sounds so - clinical - and in some ways hopeful.

This word is not appropriate for the loss of our cod fishery/ground stocks.
This word does not do justice in defining the catastrophic damage caused due to "suspension" of activity.

Somehow Canada - Ottawa - the Feds - have convinced many Newfoundlanders and Labradorians that it's our fault or at the least we are partially to blame.

Listening to Canada - or federal politicians from other provinces make this claim - is - what I can expect. Listening to our own politicians and experts making the same claim is sickening.

So how did Canadian and Newfoundland and Labrador politicians get away with the largest socio/enviro mess ever seen in this country?

1. Announce a moratorium in 1992 and claim that stocks will recover - should have been fixed by 2002. (DID NOT HAPPEN)

2. Announce programs to bridge the gap for fishermen, plantworkers, and communities (DID NOT begin to COVER LOSS)

3. Increase Fisheries Science (DID NOT HAPPEN)

4. Retirement Packages (DID NOT HAPPEN)

5. Then they slowly got us used to words like rationalization, down-sizing, and right-sizing - carefully explaining to us that the fishery was never meant to handle that many people. (BUNK)

6. From there we went to dumping FPI and eliminating marketing.

7. They closed one plant - most other plants and workers shut-up - they feared they would be next.

8. They have and continue to pit one community against another.

9. Downloading federal fishery support services to the province.

10. Pit offshore against inshore - recreational against commercial.

11. Use municipal politicians by offering pavement, arenas, tourism dollars, and water/sewer.

12. Commit to one study after another to delay any real action.

13. Pit urban residents against rural residents.

14. Promote and focus on non-renewable oil assets.

15. Above all - convince us - we were greedy, we took all the fish, and we destroyed ourselves.

16. Marginalize people like Gus Etchegary and Phil Earle.

17. Eliminate the people left with EI changes.

18. Give all fish to kingpins.

19. Over utilization of other stocks.

All of this while the FACT remains that management was the responsibility of the federal government. They were negligent. As a result we were harmed. Therefore we need compensation. 1 billion a year until the stocks return.

The Ministers of Fishery we have had federal and provincial are too gutless, ignorant, or complicit to do what is needed.


Monday, January 30, 2012

What if OCI said ICU Hebron and the little fishies went bye bye

I wonder if one of Ches Penney's companies would take a look at building a module for Hebron?
I wonder if the Government would assist to make that happen?
I wonder if the plant workers from Marystown could be appeased or at least some tradespeople?
I wonder if all that happened would government grant OCI the right to export the unprocessed fish?

Does anybody know?

I want the Auditor General to have a better look at the books. I want the whys and the processes - do you?

Tuesday, June 21, 2011

Dunderdale says of critics on Muskrat Falls Deal "working hard to find the few flaws"

Premier Dunderdale is a political fraud. Very simple - as she opens her mouth and inserts two feet in.

The Premier says we - the critics of the Muskrat Falls deal - are "working to find the few flaws". This while addressing the Oil Conference happening in St. John's today.

Dunderdale is ignorant and that is extremely dangerous for Newfoundland and Labrador.

Inheriting the title Premier - gives her a right to diminish the FREE public service many of us have been involved in for over two decades.

While trying to insult and degrade the people she serves and who pay her salary - she ironically provides a compliment.

The Premier must be in pretty bad shape when she resorts to "insulting" rather that "debating" to silence her critics.

Dunderdale should learn this lesson. As Premier she should encourage, welcome, and thank those citizens that are "working" to find flaws in the Muskrat Falls deal. That means we give a damn about our place and give a damn about future generations.

Kathy Dunderdale as Premier - the most powerful position in the Province stands and speaks to corporate executives - some of which are the most powerful people in business and takes potshots at people who are not present for the address and receives applause from those wanting to rid the people of their resources for maximum gain.

A corporation can be forgiven for the cheap and cowardice behavior - they represent their shareholders and have a fiduciary duty to make them money. They in no way are responsible for the betterment of our people and our communities. That's your job Premier - and you'll have a hard time of it if you continue to attack your own people in favour of large offshore corporations, other provinces, and Stephen Harper.

Dunderdale is setting a very poor example for your children and mine. By using an imbalance of power to assert her position - the Premier is actually a bully.

Sadly the Premier is actually targeting the people she has sworn to represent.

Without her power - she might actually have to appear in front of ordinary Newfoundlanders and Labradorians like you and me. Then she might actually have to debate with the owners of the resources - she is so flippantly giving away. On equal terms our Premier would be lost - and I assure you the applause she is receiving from the corporate elite might be replaced with disdain and disgust from the people who elected her party to govern.

If stripped of her position tomorrow - would she so freely attack others behind their backs? If stripped of her power tomorrow - would she so freely try to rid others of their gainful employment? If stripped of her power tomorrow - who would she be? Dunderdale might just find out in October. As for those Cabinet Ministers and backbenchers who are silenced either by ignorance or hopes of personal gain (cabinet post) - you should really sit back and reflect. Is this really worth it? What will your grandchildren think?

As for finding flaws - let's hope we do - those few flaws in the Upper Churchill have certainly been costly.

Ask Nova Scotia Premier Darrell Dexter if you have permission to talk to your people.

Wednesday, February 02, 2011

The Story of George Murphy - much more than gas prices!

Everybody knows George - he is the wonderful person that keeps us regularly up to date on home heating fuel and gas prices. This he does for his fellow citizens - at no charge - and is ultimately more valuable than our paid consumer representative.

George has also over the years plunked himself in the middle of other important issues concerning Newfoundland and Labrador - again at no charge. George cares about other people - no doubt about it. He cares so much the Liberals (in their usual way) used his services - at no charge.

George is a tested and true Newfoundlander and Labradorian - he deserves all the accolades he gets for the "public service" he provides. You see that really is public service and not self service. The Liberals need to gut the house and return the party back to the people. There are many George's out there - good people - who have proven their worth and love for this province.

Now George recently ran in a by-election and placed a respectable second - but George deserved to win. If it was based on public profile and service - and not on Danny's leftover team  - Brazil probably would have placed second. The Liberals continued to receive the same message - clean house - rid yourselves of the regurgitated, recycled, faceless, inner sanctum dwellers - who are just waiting for their turn again.


The Libs - sitting in wait - honestly- sitting waiting sitting waiting - for the Tories to fail. That is the lump sum ambition of what is left over there. Meanwhile more and more philosophically inclined Libs sit and wait for the Party to clean itself up. It is looking disheveled, worn, weary, and most of all lazy. They feel they are entitled to government.

The Liberals recycling of past politicos and "party-executive" program - if adopted by the provinces multi materials stewardship board - would put to shame the best efforts of green advocates.

Who does this party belong to anyway? Maybe they will tell us. The latest tour of the Province in an effort to "consult" with people is really a public relations exercise - have they listened before?

George is a good fellow - and he is now with the NDP - hope he is being respected. Because I believe in democracy - I can never say - the NDP will not win - but there has not been enough effort into building and attracting - rather just repeating the social messages of Tommy Douglas. Douglas was extraordinary - and as one voice he brought many together and thereby pushed progressive policies through.

Ultimately I suppose the story of George demonstrates the public is not requiring the best - but whatever the partisan chef serves up. In this case it was a PC. Now because I love Bell Island so much - this causes me more grief. Bell Island has always had real promise and has always been let down. Listening to Mayor Gary Gosine speak passionately of his Tickle home is as hard as listening to Gus on the fishery. Why? Because they deserve to be listened to but they are drowned out by partisan mules delivering the message of those addicted to power but allergic to service.

It's too easy for us townies to say "resettle" - to whatever community might be in difficulty. It is too easy for Islanders to say "Labrador has to understand they have little population and have to share their wealth of natural resources". That's just us being lazy and that laziness makes it easy to be partisan. All you have to do is join the chant. That's how a boy from the interior of the island - who has seen more spruce bud-worms than cod can Randy on about there is not enough fish and rural Newfoundland and Labrador just has to suck it up.

Women and men of this province - we have to step to the plate - take our precious democracy seriously - do not seek a messiah - but rather proven Newfoundlanders and Labradorians who just feel it in the gut when our province and her people hurt. We have to take a turn at bat - so that a Brad Cabana cannot be the top news story over the real issues facing us. We have to get to first base and demand our media to - bring us the real goods. How will we know when we are on our way home? When people like George Murphy are not used by the likes of what's left of the Liberal club - when we elect people based on real positions and demonstrated commitment - not somebody who calls Randy, Bill, or Paddy and says I am a first time caller and I'm running for the Williams team. How about when we take stewardship to mean something more than a word on a sign and when we say as parents - it is not good enough to put a roof over their heads and food in their bellies - rather protect our children for all your worth from the partisan power brokers and the bobble heads who follow them.

If you do not protect the next generation - your children from this - most of these politicos won't. They make sure their children have a prosperous future another way - and that hurts us all.

Hats off George and I hope you don't mind that I "used" you for this blog post. I did so with all good intentions.

Thursday, January 18, 2007

On this you have my Support

When it comes to dealing with the oil giants - Williams is on the mark. They are greedy beyond capitalist expectations - and are usually run by arrogant individuals. The negotiators and senior employees of these corporations make more in bonuses personally - by low-balling governments (owners of the resource) - in one year than most people in this province would make over 100 years.

Further it is important that industrial benefits and royalties reflect the reality of global economics at the time of agreement.

For those who wish to see the letter from government to the CNLOPB press HERE.
The response from Liberal Leader Gerry Reid was predictable and political. There are real examples of inconsistency with the Danny Regime - and even more evidence that he is a bully. He has failed miserably in the Pulp and Paper Industry - the Fishing Industry - and in the development of rural Newfoundland and Labrador. The Premier is totally inconsistent with respect to wind development - hydro development - and the promise of an energy plan. These are significant issues which need alternate policy choices and real leadership with a vision.

Unfortunately the Libs are offering little as an alternate choice. The Official Opposition offers nothing on the energy side as they believed an energy plan was not relevant let alone essential - they had Abitibi Stephenville in their hands to fix - but let the election get in the way. The Official Opposition appear to be all over and nowhere at all regarding the fishery - outside a constituency comment here and there. The saddest of all is the Great Liberal Party is grabbing headlines via Grimes and Efford - while Dumaresque claims the party tent is getting larger. While it is nice to see the boys kiss and make up - the tent is hardly getting bigger - I'm sure the size of it is actually smaller with a group of opposition critics - who still believe they are Ministers - smothering any growth with stagnant air under a leaking canvas.

Kudo's to Williams for allowing the Minister of Fields and Farms to speak on oil and gas - this might be a sign of growth in his personality - more likely it's the Peckford Syndrome kicking in - somebody - in this case Sue's Blog points out the Premier controls certain Ministerial files - and then he - to prove that wrong - will do exactly the Opposite.

International Finance reports from Bloomberg
demonstrate exactly why Premier Williams should stand firm. Here's a quote from the Story:

Newfoundland is trying to maximize benefits and capitalize on high oil prices, which reached a record of $78.40 a barrel in July, said Martin Molyneaux, a Calgary analyst with FirstEnergy Capital Corp. Crude prices have dropped about a third in the past six months and Newfoundland risks driving the oil companies away, he said.

``If I was the government of Newfoundland, I wouldn't be playing too hardball with these guys because there are lots and lots of alternatives'' to investing in Newfoundland, said Molyneaux in a telephone interview. He rates Hibernia owner Petro-Canada of Calgary as a ``top pick'' and owns an undisclosed number of shares. ``You don't want to push too far because these companies have a long history of walking away when things get ridiculous.''


You see a Calgary analyst and Petro-Canada shareholder - telling us what's best for us - is suspect at best - and typical "they are stupid Newfs" at worst. So on the issue of oil and gas - keep up the fight Premier - take em for all their worth.

And just before I post - Danny Dumaresque just finished on Open-Line with Randy Simms - and most everything he said respecting the Premier and his failures are true - but he too fell into the trap of continuing the condemnation of bullying the oil companies. Sad really and the very reason the voters will reject the Liberal candidates. The Opposition does not have alternative policy except - handle the oil companies with kid gloves. John Efford - Roger Grimes - and Walter Noel should not be responsible for rebuilding the Party - in fact it will not work. Unless you mean what you say - and treat people with respect - there will be no grand recovery by October. There's no doubt the caucus are consummate politicians - take what they can - promise what they have to - and deliver as little as possible - in order to garner votes and support. It's time now to respect what the electorate want - a real choice - a new vision - and a clean sweep of the house.

There are two clear indications of what people are saying to the Liberals. One - Danny is making mistakes and is doing little to rebuild our provinces rural economy - he lost support but it went to the undecided column.
Two - they are unprepared to go another round with the old Liberal Cabinet - without the infusion of new blood and a very different policy platform.